Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Keith Bumgarner's avatar

James, reading your post felt like catching a fly ball I didn’t know was coming—pure reflex joy.

Your mother teaching you to read a box score, your father squatting in the backyard with his catcher’s mitt and his beer, the Pizza Supreme game that old men in McLean still invoke in hushed tones—this is baseball as it was meant to be lived. Not just watched. Inhabited.

I came to it the same way. Little League, Pony League, Legion ball in a small North Carolina town where the major leagues might as well have been on the moon. No big newspaper, no TV station worth the name. Every morning I’d call the local paper just to get the scores—Cubs and Red Sox, my two chosen instruments of heartbreak.

And yes, I chose them both. Voluntarily.

That’s the thing about baseball that separates it from every other sport. You don’t have to be 7 feet tall or weigh 300 pounds. You just have to run like the wind and keep your eye on the ball—things every kid on every playground already believes he can do. The game invites you in at age seven and never quite lets you go.

I’ve sat in Wrigley Field on a warm spring afternoon, slight breeze off the lake, grass impossibly green, my Cubbies actually winning. I’ve been in nearly every major league park this country has. And in 2004, after a lifetime of Red Sox purgatory, I watched them come back from 3-1 against the Yankees—the Yankees—and then sweep the Cardinals in four. I wept. I’m not embarrassed to say it.

You asked whether baseball was better back then. I don’t know either. But I know what you mean. One-dollar Knothole Club tickets. The organ. Frank Howard actually having to earn a home run. The slowball.

Maybe it’s less about better and more about before—before we knew how it would go, before the heartbreaks had accumulated, when every April still felt like the year it was all going to turn around.

Maybe this is our year.

Francis Urquhart's avatar

Pizza Supreme, yeah. They were still talking about them, even across the river in MoCo, even when I started pee wee baseball in 1974. I never knew you were the Pizza Supreme Slayer, though. I tip my cap to you, sir.

23 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?